Saturday, October 25, 2008

Will Gandhi Work?


Sometimes, I think we are just not capable of digesting Gandhi. With Gandhi, I mean a set of ideas which were revived by a man through his own experiments, named Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi. Most of us agree that Gandhi's philosophy of non-violence is "nice", but what would happen to him if he was dealing with the likes of Adolf Hitler? Check out history books from any civilized country and you will notice that Hitler has been produced as evil monster. I do not have any problem with that as I feel Hitler deserves every iota this fame and more. But could you use Gandhian principles to destroy such a distorted morality? So, we must reach a conclusion that Gandhi and his ideals are not applicable everywhere and therefore should be discarded.(!?) Isn't that how most discussions seems to invalidate Gandhi?

I see such thinking as a result of our upbringing where everything good is judged on its merit of achieving a purpose. The method which helps us in achieving the purpose fastest, is the best! The usefulness of achieving such a purpose and the means applied to achieve these purpose does not count. So, when Gandhi wouldn't have succeeded against Hitler, how can I or anyone else succeed without violently protesting for my cause? So, eventually people end up justifying killing someone to make their voice count!

If you do not like someone or his ideas, is it okay to give yourself the right to kill him? I don’t endorse such savage justice. The path taken up by Gandhi is hard path and the right path. It takes great strength and integrity to be in the system and fight it. Instead, just blowing up the whole parliament and corrupt ministers doesn’t give us any kind of purpose. It does not help us build infrastructure or economy, protect our liberty, or remove poverty. Such acts are called terrorism by any civilized perspective.

If you really wish to achieve peace and harmony, your disapproval of Gandhian principles appear completely hypocritical and illogical. We have this tendency to blame others for our own miseries. We blame the English for the partition and with some incoherent - stupid - piggish logic, even Gandhi. But, why is it so hard to accept that the actual cause of failure is the seeds of hatred that we sow in our minds and heart on everyday basis? 

The caste system is our oldest means to discriminate each other. Also, we have so many religions amidst us with each having its own level of superiority complex, moreover there are different cultures and races. Such hatred starts in mind as we start publicly display our ignorance of history and logic by asking questions like; Why do they eat non-veg? Why don't they drink? Why do they look like Chinese? How can I eat food touched by him? And the list is endless! 

Gandhi tried, throughout his life, to remove these differences, his idea was simple, be the change that you want to see in the world, learn to love and respect others although he is quite different from you.

I had been meeting people people since the time I left school who try to impose their (misguided) intelligence on me by contradicting every action of Gandhi by either stupid nonsensical logic or hypothetical plot which never happened, just like the one in the first paragraph. Consciously, I have stopped forcing myself to answer them. But I couldn't feel sorry for them and stop wondering, "No human who knows a little bit of history can come to the conclusion that Gandhi was responsible for the partition. It is their ignorance which speaks under their frail veil of intelligence."

People usually forget that non-violence does not mean making peace. On the other hand, it means fighting bravely and sincerely for truth and doing what is just. Like all fights, there will be a terrible loss and pain but it takes courage and patience to fight against injustice without losing your sanity and killing people in moment of rage. You cannot just expect things to change overnight, it takes a lot of character to be Gandhi or follow his path and make it work.

2 comments:

ramu said...

I didnt get baba's words completely, but i m saying my views for gandhi jee. whatever wrong has been done due to his actions, but his intention was not wrong. he want to make india independent, remove castism and clean our society. I prefer to say that if someone want to do good things, we should motivate him or her at least. well baba m i right?

Unknown said...

gr88 yaar...
as far i can understand..when we talk of Gandhiji or any other proponent of non - violence...then the idea of non violence becomes greater than the individual himself...means as an individual maybe the idea wud hv been dangerous for his life standing against what Hitler stood for...but for evolution of human race an ideological xperiment wud hv started...